Friday, November 14, 2008

“Beyond the Illusions” by Sheeba Shivangini Shah

Today we discussed the book “Beyond the Illusions” by Sheeba Shivangini Shah. The meeting took place at 1:30 pm at the British Council, Lazimpat. It was heartening to see more than 20 participants at the meet. All public vehicles were off the road due to the bandh, but the readers walked all the way to the venue regardless of how far they lived. This proves that our club will keep going strong, rain or shine!

The meeting began with a brief “author interview” section, where participants asked the author questions regarding her reading habits, interests, personal life, and so on.

On to the book! …

A fair number of folks had read the book, so the discussion was pretty intense. Many ideas shared between readers and the author alike. Many participants criticized the book for having rather flat characters and somewhat difficult language. But the main lament appeared to be how unclear the book’s stance was, because the “moral” of it all appeared a bit ambiguous.

Clarifying on this, the author stated that she had deliberately left an open ending, giving free reign to the reader to make his or her own opinions on matters such as spirituality, godliness, sexuality, tantric practices, womanism, etc…

The whole issue of materialism vs. spiritualism was also discussed in great detail, with each participant sharing their own point of view on how each one of us could achieve happiness in life.

We are very grateful to all the participants and the novelist for joining us today and helping to make this meeting a great success. Sheeba Shivangini Shah is working on her third novel that deals with three generations. We wish her luck on the new book!

Beyond The Illusions “Review”

Wacky!!!

Yes, the book is wacky but it is wonderful too. It took me a long time to finish. It was hard to read but I succeded to finish the book.

The work of the Nepali writer Sheeba Shivangani Shah is really appreciable. The novel however lacks many things. The main thing it lacks is the flow. (This might be my personal feeling). The language is too awkward too. Hard to understand and more than this hard to believe is the tantric practices.

Beyond the illusions is a novel which somehow makes you contemplate in the sense that it teaches us the way towards godhood and also urges us to find god within self. However the shocking evidences inside an ashram is hard to believe.

The writer has done a lot of hard work that is really appreciable. The hard work lies in providing us the truth of Tantric practices, the evidences and the real events. I read her interview as well and yes it is true the writer had really worked hard to bring this book.

The Novel is about the search for the true self, the god inside our soul within us, our own longing for the eternal truth, the bliss and the point of Nirvana. Bharavi, the protagonist happens to suffer so much and at the end she is able to find god within herself. The story blend of fact and fiction seems to be awesome but it is kind of soft porn, really hard to read and even sometimes unreadable.

The family tragedy at one place, the love and longing for a husband and the desire of wife and again the reversing story is wonderful. How Jayanta ( Bharavi’s Husband ) happens to leave his home in search of the Nirvana, and how Bharavi leaves her home to find and bring back Jayanta to the normal self but happens is just opposite, Bahravi finds out the Nirvana, who was never in search of it and Jayanta chooses normal Life in the end.

I felt pang when I read about molestation and abuse of female body such that it sounds unnatural and totally unreadable and also that happening in Tantra, unimaginable. It was really hard to believe the sexual activities involved in tantra.

The character Sadashiva lacks poetic justice for he receives death untimely, with the hand of the same creator who had held his hands when he was helpless and had become his gaurdian, his Guru. There I felt, if Bharavi had the powers then she should have stopped Swami killing his own loved disciple and also the one who loved and cared Bhairavi like nothing.

Moreover I enjoyed reading. The things about Kali fascinated me like nothing. It was really nice to learn to find god within myself. We should really appreciate this book for what it is. It is nice to read ….I must say this..as I enjoyed reading and when I finished reading I said to myself -: Thank God I could complete.

Dark side of Tantra

Sheeba Shivangini Shah's debut historical fiction, Loyals of the Crown, was an excellent work on King Rajendra and his wives with the writer emphasizing how loyal relatives and courtiers spoiled Nepal's royals. Recently, she has come up with her second book Beyond the Illusions — "a saga of sexual slavery involved in tainted Tantric rituals". Here, she deals particularly with Shakta Tantrism, which includes the worship of the matrikas and fierce goddesses.

The violent death of her parents-in-law and the loss of her own elder brother left a deep scar in Shivangini's psyche, prompting her to devote the book to her late brother's memory. Her in-laws — Kumar Khadga Bikram Shah and his wife Princess Sharada — died of bullet wounds sustained during the Royal Massacre. Similar was the fate of her elder brother, who died at the hands of Maoist rebels. The young writer's weary heart has sought solace in writing about the power of death and destruction as represented by Kali and the quest for the ultimate truth beyond life. Shivangini's conclusion: "Life is a mere illusion, the truth is beyond it, and to connect with this infinite truth, a complete renunciation of illusions must be made."

The story begins with an omnipresent narrator who is Shivangini herself in the form of a young television producer for Kasthamandap Channel. As the plot unfolds, the readers are told that she has a special mission in Delhi — meeting a Tantric yogi named Swami Satyananda. Once the meeting takes place, the writer switches over to a third person narrative and there is a metanarrative of a barren woman, Bhairavi, and her transformation into a deity.

Bhairavi—the flamboyant daughter-in-law of the "illustrious" Dhodi family who loves to adorn herself in richly embroidered saris and neatly-cut kurtas from Shahab Durazi to Manish Malhotra and Neeta Lulla—is the protagonist of the story. Why is Bhairavi barren? It was her destiny to be childless, to lose her husband and go searching for him to the holy city of Rishikesh in India, to be initiated into Tantrism and get transformed into a living incarnate of the fiery Goddess Kali or Adi Shakti

Swami Shri Maharaj Satyananda initiates Bhairavi into Tantrism. The period of initiation described in the book probably lasted over several weeks. It starts with some basic teaching from the Swami that "the self is important" and that Bhairavi should "learn to love herself". The yogi tells her that Kali is the great delusion; she is the void into which the entire universe is submerged, and it is the realization of this very truth that is taught at the ashram. He also tells her that she is the "chosen" one and that she must be his disciple; to do otherwise would be to deny the human race the eternal knowledge that she possesses. He teaches her that sexual energy is an integral part of Tantra and that she must overcome shame to indulge in pure sex and unite with the primordial energy.

A cursory reading is enough to gauge the amount of research that Shivangini did on Tantrism before writing the novel. She has boldly narrated the complex Tantric ritual involved in Shakta Tantrism, which particularly believes in the worship of different parts of the female body before engaging in sexual union. Below is a paragraph from the book that gives an example of Shivangini's fine prose and her superb handling of Tantric terminology.

"One night Swami Shri Maharaj Satyananda took Bhairavi to the inner courtyard, the secret and much concealed area where only the privileged were allowed. As she followed him, enveloped in the same void, she watched the reflection from the Swami's lantern sweep across the walls of the long corridor… There, in front of the stone image of the goddess, he undressed Bhairavi. He made her stand naked by the divine figurine and started touching each bare part, reciting the mantras of Kama-Kala."

The basic tenet of Shakta Tantrism is that a woman possesses more spiritual energy than man; therefore, man can achieve realization of the divinity only through sexual and emotional union with woman. Swami Satyananda wants "to invoke the Goddess in humans and worship the Great Mother in living form" so as to attain cosmic consciousness. To fulfill his petty motives, he goes on raping "innocent" women whom he calls the 10 living incarnates of the Goddess Kali. The first was Dhoonka and the second, Bhairavi. Ironically, the third victim is deemed to be Shivangini herself. It must be noted that the alluring words the Swami uses for Shivangini are actually the same that he uses for Bhairavi. Both are the names of Shakti deities. That means the fictional Shivangini could have been the next victim of the Swami's lust had he not lost his sanity after his intense erotic misadventures with Bhairavi.

There are places not only in India but also in Nepal where hundreds of innocent women are brutally raped by sex-starved swamis or followers of some stupid cult in the name of religion. Therefore, the revelations in Beyond the Illusions on the Swami's penchant for raping women in the name of religion will certainly inspire readers to give a second thought to many such cults prevailing in Nepal, such as the Badi and Deuki traditions where sex is part of the religious rituals.

The inherent message of the novel is that Tantra alone is not enough without Mantra and Yantra. The trinity as a whole is not to be fragmented in the universal and cosmic scheme of things. Otherwise, the cult of the occult will produce dangerous and destructive results, which will devour the perpetrator or practitioner himself, as seen in the demented end of the Swami.


By Monica Regmi, Kantipur Publications

Loyals of the Crown

Loyals of the Crown proves itself to be distinct both in terms of its approach, aptitude and presentation. It bubbles with the enthusiasm to probe deep into the conclaves of the most controversial. The author endeavors to fill in the vacuum created by the past generation of historians and literalist and have proven the fact that history is not merely an elucidation of single protagonist and events and activities surrounding them. History as she puts it is an episode, which has peripheral dimensions where a multitude of characters, events and activities needs to be taken into consideration.

This is what she has done describing the temperament and idiosyncrasies of His Majesty King Rajendra in a manner, which has been completely ignored by earlier writers. She depicts him, not as a senile, incompetent, irrational and schizophrenic personality , but speaks of his concealed attributes and describes him as a loving husband, an intriguing diplomat, and a true nationalist. It is also clear that his wives, his courtiers and 'Darbarias' exploited his weaknesses to the fullest extent and whilst pretending to be 'Loyal' betrayed him and usurped the royal governance. The Royals as she projects them were never able to make correct and sane judgments in selecting the 'Loyal' thus those who were truly loyal in due course of time would either be dumped or assassinated as was epitomized by the fates of both Mathbir Singh Thapa and Bhimsen Thapa.

Written as historical fiction with the underlying romantic activities of the Royal court providing the base for the story line; this novel provides us with a unique view of life as it was in the Nepali court in the pre-Rana era. It also provides us with insight into the scenario behind Jung Bahadur's usurping of the royal authority and the establishing of the Rana dynasty that ruled Nepal with an iron hand for one hundred and four years. "I personally would recommend the research scholars, the historians and other writers to go through the Loyal of the Crown, which has attempted to answer many questions that had remained unattended either intentionally or our of ignorance by the conventional historians of Nepal." -- Diwaker Chand